While watching this video, I realized how technology has become such an integral part of education. I think it was really fortunate for the students in West Philadelphia to be a part of that experience. However there are some disadvantages that go along with having a school functioning solely on technology. Advantages may include things being a lot more convenient and easily accessible to the students. Each student is provided a laptop and that is pretty much all they need to do any of their assignments. The video also mentioned that there haven't been many incidents of theft and the most common problem students have to face is forgetting passwords.
On the other hand, there are problems that can arise with having a technological school. There could be issues with file or system corruption, hackers, or even power flux. They only have a few things that they rely on for instruction. Naturally, there would be grave repercussions if they couldn't even use those tools. Also, a woman they interviewed named Kathy Lee was also not completely agreeing with the situation. Out of a scale of 1 through 10, she rated the efficiency of the place a 4. She makes a really good point when she mentions that it's important for students to not only consult and rely on a machine, but social interaction with peers and teachers is also important for intellectual growth. I did see that there was some interaction between the teachers and students, but not as much as we're used to.
As for the money they used to build the school, I think it was good that they used that much for a school to reach it's full potential. However, I also think that it's just as effective as improving an already capable school using textbooks, etc.
So, I think their intentions with making a technological school were good, but even they won't know the full effect of this experience until the pilot students graduate. Monitoring the students by constantly testing them is also a great way to see the progress with the change.
That's what I think! =]
No comments:
Post a Comment